Preliminary Nuke the Mask Experiment
Okay Mr. Wizard what was the result of your experiment.
“Help me, Mr. Wizard, I don’t want to be Contaminated any more!”
“Drizzle, Drazzle, Druzzle, Drome; time for this one to come home.”
…
Hypothesis: Disposable medical and surgical masks could be effectively steamed in an home microwave oven to reuse.
Objective: Safely steam heat different types of nonwoven fiber, cloth, and paper mask to sufficient heat with steam per prescribed CDC references. Achieve 160°F(71C) for 3 to 5 minutes without melting the plastic bag or destroying mask while saturating with steam. Secondary objectives were to not destroy the microwave, start a fire, contaminate the entire kitchen, or get thrown out of the house.
Method: Nuke the crap out of current N95 and Non N95 masks in a 1,000 Watt Microwave Oven (preferrably without destroying it or otherwise pissing off the missus) while controlling cross contamination.
Materials:
Frigidare 1KW Microwave oven 2450MHz with glass rotating stage @ 3min, 3min 30 sec, 4 min
Great Value Double Zip Quart Storage Bags
Bounty Paper Towels
Tap Water
Surgical Gloves
Needle Nose Pliers
Scotch Magic Tape
Exacto Knife
Tweezers
Kitchen Tongs
GDealer Digital probe thermometer (-50 to 300C)
Discussion:
Masks were carefully inspected and aluminum nose strip removed using Exacto knife and tweezers leaving small slot to reinsert aluminum strips. One resembled a plastic coated wire tie rather versus the flat mallable aluminum strip.
Each mask was flattened and wrapped in a fairly well saturated double thickness paper towel and inserted into the ziplock plastic bag. The mouth of the bag was closed but not zipped to let the steam escape.
Each bag was nuked (irradiated) for 3 to 4 minutes until the digital thermometer indicated 160F. The bag was left in the closed microwave for an additional two three minutes to ensure saturation and apply supplemental internal alcohol disinfectant solution to the experimental staff.
3 minute irradiation seemed to achieve good level of steam and 140° to 150°F temperature. At 3 min 30 sec 160° to 168°F was observed. At 4 minutes in the largest mask the indicated temperature was 198 to 204°F and it maintained above 165°F in the bag for 3 minutes or more. Exact temperature decay data is not clear to to additional prophylactic applications of ethanol decontamination fluid.
Noted is after 5 or more 3 to 4 successive irradiation steam sessions, minor to no puckering of the mask was noted. The bottom of the ziplock bag was not melted, but starting to seriously pucker and thin.
Additional experiments with better test setup will be performed as soon as we can find a microwave withan external temp probe and more of the decontamination fluid.
Limitations noted include no definitive known innoculants on the mask. No in situ temperature measurement with internal probe or humidity measurement. Need to use a heavier guage plastic heating bag or per the papers in references a dedicated microwave steaming bag. Insufficient decontamination and sterilzation fluid to repeat the experiment for statistical rigor.
…
Draft Procedure
Home Sterilization of N95 type conformal fitted face respirators.
You can’t just keep wearing the face respirators without real fear of introducing contamination by either touching the surface or inadvertantly placing the masks on a clean surface contaminating your house or office. Recent data has shown SARS CoV2 remains on cloth for 2 days and surgical masks for up to 7 days.
Research has shown Microwave Generated Steam (MSG) is effective in mask decontamination. From the CDC, " The microwaves produced by a “home-type” microwave oven (2.45 GHz) completely inactivate bacterial cultures, mycobacteria, viruses, and G. spores within 60 seconds to 5 minutes depending on the challenge organism.
Another study confirmed these resuIts but also found that higher power microwaves in the presence of water may be needed for sterilization.
Complete destruction of Mycobacterium bovis was obtained with 4 minutes of microwave exposure (600W, 2450 MHz)"
“Moist heat, consisting of 60°C and 80% RH caused minimal degradation in the filtration and fit performance of the tested FFRs [3, 9, 10]. Heimbuch et al. disinfected FFRs contaminated with H1N1 using moist heat, of 65°C and 85% RH, and achieved a minimal of 99.99% reduction in virus [14]. One limitation of the moist heat method is the uncertainty of the disinfection efficacy for various pathogens”
"Steam treatment and liquid hydrogen peroxide are promising methods with some limitations
"Decontaminate six FFR models and achieved 99.9% inactivation of MS2 bacteriophage. Filtration performance of all tested FFRs scored above NIOSH certification requirements. Three FFRs were further evaluated for three cycles of steam exposure and demonstrated no change in filtration performance [15]. Bergman et al. also demonstrated acceptable filtration performance after three cycles of exposure to microwave generated steam [3]. Microwave generated steam had little effect on FFR fit after exposure to up to three cycles of steam [9, 10].
Using microwaves to produce steam to decontaminate FFRs is not without limitations. Not all microwaves are constructed the same and some are more powerful than others. The effect of higher power microwaves on FFRs is unknown. Furthermore, the metal nosebands of FFRs may cause arcing, sparks inside the microwave oven, during exposure to microwaves."
From remarks on “Put disposable N95 masks in microwave kill coronavirus resuse” blog by the physician, “As per earlier comment, if N95 has metal strip, microwave for 30 seconds, wait 30 to 45 seconds, microwave for 30 seconds, etc… Let the metal cool down. Best to repeat 4 – 5 times with cool down each time. One mask at a time only is what doctor stated.” TBD.
“To date, there’s little research on microwaving Covid-19. However research on human parainfluenza – an RNA virus just like Covid-19 – has been done. These scientists from the Department of Microbiology at Oklahoma State University concluded that running a microwave on high for 3 minutes was enough to disinfect plastic petri dishes.Microwaving parainfluenza for 3 minutes kills virus”.
"Reusing filtering facepiece respirators (FFRs) has been suggested as a strategy to conserve available supplies for home and healthcare environments during an influenza pandemic.
For reuse to be possible, used FFRs must be decontaminated before redonning to reduce the risk of virus transmission; however, there are no approved methods for FFR decontamination. An effective method must reduce the microbial threat, maintain the function of the FFR, and present no residual chemical hazard. The method should be readily available, inexpensive and easily implemented by healthcare workers and the general public. Many of the general decontamination protocols used in healthcare and home settings are unable to address all of the desired qualities of an efficient FFR decontamination protocol.
The goal of this study was to evaluate the use of two commercially available steam bags, marketed to the public for disinfecting infant feeding equipment, for FFR decontamination.
The FFRs were decontaminated with microwave generated steam following the manufacturers’ instructions then evaluated for water absorption and filtration efficiency for up to three steam exposures. Water absorption of the FFR was found to be model specific as FFRs constructed with hydrophilic materials absorbed more water. The steam had little effect on FFR performance as filtration efficiency of the treated FFRs remained above 95%.
The decontamination efficacy of the steam bag was assessed using bacteriophage MS2 as a surrogate for a pathogenic virus. The tested steam bags were found to be 99.9% effective for inactivating MS2 on FFRs; however, more research is required to determine the effectiveness against respiratory pathogens."
My experiment to disinfect respirator masks…will let you know!
YOU MUST REMOVE THE METAL STRIP!
- Wash
- Gloves
- Remove Mask by strings and deposit on disposable paper toweling or paper.
- Cut slot at top of mask and Remove Metal strip using tweezers or needle nose pliers
- Wrap mask with heavily moistened paper towel to generate consistent steam heating of mask surface
- Place in Paper Sack to prevent contamination of Microwave surfaces and contain steam
- Nuke per CDC instructions. Goal is 68 C at 85%RH for several minutes
- Wash and Change Gloves
- Recover Nuked Respirator Mask to “clean” paper towel and dispose of moist HOT towel in covered sanitary waste bag
- Reinsert 70% alchohol or 0.05% bleach sanitized metal strip
- Allow to dry
- Seal mask in disposable plastic Bag Respirator for “2??” days
- Wipe down microwave surface with approved virucide.
- Cycle respirator back into service on third day.
- Be aware of cross contamination in handling exposed mask surfaces…
https://www.google.com/amp/s/boomers-daily.com/2020/03/20/health-put-disposable-n95-masks-in-microwave-kill-coronavirus-resuse/amp/